Stuck for juicy blog fodder Too curious for my own good, I finally contacted Nicole, girlfriend of 21 years ago whom I found dangling there in two dimensions on Facebook some weeks back. The post drew a lot of comments, some very thought-provoking. About half were in favour if my contacting her again, the other half saying, nah - just let the past stay in the past.
What intrigued me about the whole story is part of my growing interest in how we adapt to the rapidly changing capabilities offered by new technologies.
Twenty years ago, no-one would never have even been put in the position of having to decide whether or not to click a button to re-establish contact with anyone. The process would have been so difficult, so time-consuming, it would have taken on the aura of obsession.
But now it’s so easy, it’s like: why the hell not?
So I did.
Here’s what I wrote her:
Hi Nicole,
West End Vancouver, summer of Expo ‘86? Four months of fun and three months of none? How are you? Are you still nursing? In case you’ve ever wondered what became of that guy who didn’t know what to do with the rest of his life, here’s a short update for you. I quit wasting my time with that awful job with those awful people, went skiing for a while and kicked around a bit, left Vancouver two years later to live in Montreal, went back to school for journalism, worked as a reporter in Sherbrooke and Hong Kong, where I met my wife and where my daughter was born. We’ve been living in Hamburg, Germany for the past decade. I’m still in media and still enjoying it. Hey, guess what? That post-university quarter-life crisis I was going through when you knew me? It now has its own label, website, support group and everything! And you can now - perhaps too easily - get ahold of old girlfriends on Facebook, but believe me: I hesitated a long time before hitting the send button.
Pretty much what I said I’d write.
She answered right away.
Here’s what she wrote:
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
I don’t want to be mean or anything but i don’t know you. I’ve never seen you in my life.
I think you must have the wrong person.
I’ve never been to Vancouver.
and in 1986 I was only 12 years old and i didn’t have a b/f.
I’m happy to hear that you have success in your life and that you found the right girl.
I still can’t believe it.
Looks exactly like her, and the age she should be. Same name. Does this sort of thing happen every day?
Her full profile - now that I can see it, because I couldn’t when I wrote that other post - puts her birthdate in 1974, so yeah, she would have been around 12.
Good thing it wasn’t her, or I’d probably have a few jail stories to tell.
© 2007 lettershometoyou









Oh, my. A shrieking wince short of Schadenfreude.
Thank heavens she attributed your mail to a mistake and not to a dragueur action.
Hilarious that you decided to contact her, and when you did, it wasn’t her. At least she didn’t pretend to be Nicole, allow you to become friends again and then reveal that she’s a 55-year-old man living in Korea.
Wow. What an incredibly strange montage of emotions to deal with. Seems it would be distressing, relieving, embarrassing all at the same time. Not to mention anticlimactic!
You have a good story to tell and you’re not in jail. And, and let’s face it: the consequences to giving into the great Facebook temptation could have been much worse!
I laughed at this, really… i feel kind of bad, but at least she took it well.
Will you continue your quest?
well it made for a couple of very interesting posts
very interesting indeed. Like how I was so thoroughly convinced it was her, I dispensed with the preliminaries of, “aren’t you the one who…” to dive right in there with my life story. And now that I can see her other photos, they look even more like her. It’s all so surreal. What are the chances of this happening? I’ve met people with my exact name, but they looked nowhere like me.
charlotte, I would have been less surprised if it HAD been a 55-year-old Korean…
adam: quest officially put on hold.
molly: she’s married to boot, goes to hockey games it appears…
Honestly, wow. She has a Doppelgänger.
Here’s a weird, but possible twist: ID security conscious folks never put the real year of their birth in public website fields. So, maybe she had a really creative way of avoiding contact.
But following the same train of thought, it’s a well-known fact that not just everyone puts up authentic photos. Or even authentic names. With that mix, nearly anything is possible.
I’ve heard of cases where people snoop out ghosts from their pasts by using a fake gmail addy…so easy to do. If this urge ever arises again, that could be another approach.
After reading the previous comment I made, scratch that last fake id idea. People do it, but IMHO it’s time for a resurgence of authenticity and respect! Screen names are fine when everyone knows that’s what they are, but dishonesty, when one person knows and the other doesn’t is something else again.
I salute what you did, out there in the open, and hope she was authentic too. Totally funny.
Oh man, first, I can’t believe you contacted her! But you know, I can understand, too. The temptation IS just too great. Second, amazing that after all that, it’s not her. Kind of a relief, though.
Seriously laughing my ass off over here. Now she’s going to tell all her friends about the pervy dude who’s stalking her on Facebook! Bwahahahaha!
ybonesy: that’s the heart of the matter. It was simply too tempting not to do it. It’s too easy. And you’re right about the relief part. I was thinking, OK - what if she wants to be “friends?” Do I say yes? What then? We would never have been friends beyond the initial re-establishment contact.
Ritergal: I was thinking the same thing about the birthday, but then again, would you really put in a birthday that’s a dozen years off? If so, she’s fooling more than 200 people on facebook.
BrownAmazon: That would be funny if she did that. She has a boatload of facebook friends, so maybe I should send her the link to both posts?
I GASPED out loud when I read her response (and then I laughed a bit..sorry… ). It’s funny, after reading your whole experience, I had to sit there for a minute and think: “did that seriously just happen to him?” Like how does such a thing happen in real life? But I guess the idea of “what could happen in real life” is ever-expanding, when you throw technology into the mix…
romi41 - for better or worse, I’m a what-you-see-is-what-you-get sorta guy. I swear, I made none of this up. I’m no stranger to self-deprecating humour, but that would be a step beyond.
I know, and that’s why I had to gasp, because I knew deep-down that you couldn’t be making it up…I really did like your message though, just the way you described your time together, and how far you’ve come….I hope you come across her (the real her) someday, so you can put it to good use
Nice story, nice resolution. I don’t think I’ll ever find my 5th great crush Tanna Moore. Her name is too common. We moved and I lost her number, so it ended in heartbreak. Never saw or heard from her again. She’s probably married and fat now.
Ha! This made me laugh. And there you were sweating bullets while waiting for the reply, eh? Probably for the best that it wasn’t her after all. I wonder if she thought it was funny being “poked” by a perfect stranger.
That was pretty funny! I guess it’s a good thing you said you were married to make it clear that you weren’t trying to hook up with her.
The internet and/or facebook has another advantage: total anonymity to shield you from embarassing situations like this.
But if this is one of the biggest worries in your life, then your life is pretty good, isn’t it?
I still think she just shaved a few years off her age and doesn’t want to hear from anyone who knows how old she REALLY is.
rain - you may have something there. An old trick!
John - yes, things are pretty good here. I can’t even say it was a worry. More like an unsatisfied curiosity.
christina - she was really nice about it. After I sent her a msg back saying I was so convinced it was her, and sorry to bother, she said it was no problem, nice knowing she has a double with the same name out there.
indie - LOL! that’s a good reason to let memories stay that way.
I got booted off of facebook for NOT using my real name. I joined to keep up on family news etc, but even though I AM a 55 yr old man from Canada, there is no way in heaven or earth I would put private details of my life — even real public ones like my name — on something as wide open as facebook.
Cheers,
Papa Bear
Papa Bear - I kind of regret not inventing some sort of name for myself on facebook that sounds real but isn’t. An alias, in other words. To get around it I have set my privacy levels at “block the universe” so that nobody can find me on a search. If anyone gets to see anything, I have to contact them first. At least I assume that’s the case. I have no idea if people who are friends of friends on facebook can also see more than my basic profile, but I hope not.
See? Everything worked out just fine.
That’s going to end up being me one day! Sorry for your troubles, but I do hope you meet up with your friend one day.